|Year : | Volume
| Issue : | Page :
Evaluation of burden felt by caregivers of patients with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder
Kajal Jitendrakumar Tanna
Department of Psychiatry, GMERS Medical College, Junagadh, Gujarat, India
|Date of Submission||10-Feb-2021|
|Date of Acceptance||13-May-2021|
|Date of Web Publication||20-Jul-2021|
Kajal Jitendrakumar Tanna,
Associate Professor Psychiatry, GMERS Medical College, Junagadh, Gujarat
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: It can be a difficult task to provide care to the patients living with mental health issues, especially with chronic diseases such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder where the patient loses touch with reality. Aim: The current study was aimed to assess the of burden of care that caregivers feel while giving care to the patients of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder and to compare the difference in burden between these two conditions. The study also evaluated the factors affecting the caregiver's burden. Settings and Design: This was a cross-sectional interview-based study conducted at the psychiatry department of a tertiary care hospital in Gujarat among caregivers of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Subjects and Methods: Each caregiver was given the Zarit-Burden Interview scale in vernacular language and asked to rate each statement from 0 to 4 where 0: never, 1: rarely, 2: sometimes, 3: quite frequently, and 4: nearly always. The final score was calculated and interpreted as: 0–21 – little or no burden, 41–60 – moderate to severe burden, and 61–88 – severe burden. Statistical Analysis: Data of the burden score were expressed as mean and standard deviation and compared using unpaired t-test. Pearson's correlation coefficient was used for correlation between burden score and variables such as age, years of education, and duration of illness. The analysis was done using GraphPad version 3.0 and Microsoft Excel 2016. Results: A total of 210 caregivers reported the interview scale completely, of which 105 caregivers belonged to schizophrenia group and 105 were related to bipolar disorder. Average of burden score was 64.89 ± 15.7 and 59.11 ± 17.8 (maximum score: 88) in schizophrenia and bipolar group, respectively, and difference between the group was statistically significant. In both the groups, it was found that, with increase in the age of patients, caregiver's burden significantly increased. Conclusion: Caregivers of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder patients feel a considerable burden of care with more burden felt by the caregivers of schizophrenia. The more vulnerable to burden are females, elderly, low-income groups, and patients in whom longer duration of care is required. The caregivers should receive an adequate support for maintaining their own mental health. they should be provided support for maintaining their mental health. Particularly, vulnerable are females, elderly, low-income groups, and longer duration of care. They should be provided with adequate support.
Keywords: Bipolar disorder, burden, caregivers, mental health, schizophrenia
It is very demanding and challenging to take care of patients living with mental health issues, particularly in India, where the social stigma of being labeled “Mentally ill” by even consulting a psychiatrist is prevalent. In a study conducted at five major cities in India, participants displayed overall high levels of perceived stigma, with female participants showing higher levels of perceived stigma compared to male counterparts. Such a level of stigma with a high prevalence of psychiatry disorders and gradual de-institutionalization of the treatment of psychiatry disorders can result in significant stress to the caregivers. Caregivers also need the social support to prevent their exhaustion in caring and maintaining their own mental health. Hence, we should have an understanding about the factors associated with burden of care for reducing it. Various studies have been conducted globally including India for assessing the difference in caregivers' burden in various population groups. Some studies have demonstrated that the caregivers of patients with psychiatry illness feel more burden than patients with other chronic medical illness.,,,, Furthermore, few pieces of research also pointed out that the caregivers feel more burden in caring patients with psychotic symptoms compared to the patients with only mood symptoms.,,, However, because of cultural and various other factors, burden becomes highly subjective and variable. For example, ethnic minorities such as Asians are more tolerant than the people from western parts to psychiatry patients in their families. India is a country with wide cultural diversities. The studies in this regard are sparse in Gujarat and to understand the burden that caregiver's feel to a psychiatry illness is still open to in-depth study in our region. Hence, the present study was designed to understand the difference between the burden felt by caregivers of schizophrenia patients and patient with bipolar disorders. The author also tried to understand whether there is any relation between various patient and caregiver variables such as age, sex, years of education, occupation, and the burden a caregiver feels.
| Subjects and Methods|| |
Type of study
The study design was a cross-sectional, observational study.
The study was conducted at psychiatry outpatient department of a tertiary care Medical College level hospital. The healthy adult primary caregivers of patients with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder were included.
Nonprobability purposive sampling was used.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Accompanying adult healthy caregivers of patients with a confirmed diagnosis of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder as per Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders – V, in symptomatic phase, diagnosed and on continuous treatment for at least 6 months, aged >18 years, and willing to participate were included in the study. A primary caregiver is the person who takes primary responsibility for someone who cannot care for himself or herself. In case, if more than one caregiver was accompanying, a primary caregiver who provides day-to-day care and support to patient, takes decisions regarding treatment, and is responsible for giving medicines to patient, was included. Caregivers of patients with a history of recent hospitalization, a major change in diagnosis and management within 3 months, and caregivers with diagnosed psychiatry illness were excluded.
Zarit burden interview
The Zarit burden interview (ZBI) is a self-reporting structured scale where the caregivers are asked to rate 22 Questions from 0 to 4 – where – 0: never, 1: rarely, 2: sometimes, 3: quite frequently, and 4: nearly always, making a total score of 88. Dimensions reported include consequences of caregiving, patient's dependence, exhaustion and uncertainty, guilt or self-criticism, embarrassment/anger or frustration, psychological burden and emotional reactions, personal strain, and role strain. Here, the author has restricted the interpretation of the global 22-item score only. The final score was interpreted as: 0–21-little or no burden, 21–40 – mild-to-moderate burden, 41–60 – moderate-to-severe burden, and 61–88 – severe burden. The ZBI scale is prevalidated, and translation to vernacular language is also prevalidated. It has shown satisfactory psychometric properties such as internal consistency, convergent and discriminative validity, and sensitivity to change to assess the caregivers' burden.
The caregivers of the selected patients were given an information sheet and explained about the study. After their written informed consent, they were given the prevalidated ZBI scale – Version 1 – with 22 items – Gujarati for use in India. Gujarati is the vernacular language of the region. They were given adequate time to understand the questionnaire and encouraged to ask the questions for any doubts regarding the study or questionnaire.
This was cross-sectional study without any major ethical considerations. Patients' or caregivers' identities were never compromised or revealed anywhere. All the participants were enrolled voluntarily after obtaining written informed consent. Permission from the Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC) obtained with letter no. IEC/26/2019 dated November 11, 2019, and this IEC is registered by Registration no. ECR/1199/Inst/GJ/2019.
Data collected were entered into the excel sheet and analyzed using GraphPad InStat version 3, Manufactured by GraphPad Software, San Diego, CA, USA. Descriptive analysis was used as a tool for factors affecting caregivers' burden, unpaired Student's t-test was applied for comparison of burden score between schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
Pearson correlation coefficient was used for estimating the correlation between patient's age, education, caregivers' age, years of education, and duration of illness with the burden score. Chi-square test was used for comparing categorical variables. For all statistical tests, P < 0.05 was considered significant.
| Results|| |
A total of 232 caregivers were provided with the ZBI scale, of which 22 interview survey forms were discarded due to missing information for evaluation. Thus, a total 210 survey forms were analyzed. Out of 210 caregivers, 105 were of patients of bipolar disorder and 105 caregivers were of patients of schizophrenia.
Demographic profiles of patients and caregivers are shown in [Table 1]. In both the groups, male caregivers were more than the female caregivers. Demographic characteristics were comparable between both the study groups as Mann–Whitney U-test applied between the group variables found the difference between groups to be statistically insignificant.
|Table 1: Demographic variables of patients and caregivers of both groups|
Click here to view
As shown in [Table 2], average ZBI score (maximum score 88) was 59.11 (17.80) in caregivers of the bipolar disorder group and 64.89 (15.66) in caregivers of schizophrenia group. Thus, caregivers of both the groups felt moderate-to-severe burden. However, burden felt by caregivers of schizophrenic patients was significantly higher than the burden felt by caregivers of bipolar patients (P < 0.05).
[Table 3] shows the relationship between ZBI scores and patient variables such as age, years of education, and duration of illness. In bipolar group, patient's age and duration of illness were significantly correlated with burden score (P < 0.05), meaning with increase in age of patients and increase in duration of treatment led to increase in burden of care, significantly. In the schizophrenia group, no significant correlation was found for any variable with burden score. Patient's sex was found not to have statistically significant correlation with burden in any group.
[Table 4] shows the relationship between ZBI score and caregivers' variables. In bipolar group, with an increase in age of caregivers, the burden was increasing, which was statistically significant (P < 0.05). In schizophrenia group, less duration of education was associated with significantly more burden in caregivers (P value < 0.05).
[Table 5] shows the relationship of caregiver's occupation with the ZBI score. In schizophrenia group, the highest burden was felt by laborers and housewives than other groups. In the bipolar group, the highest burden was felt in retired/unemployed and students than other groups.
[Table 6] depicts the relationship between caregivers' burden and relation of caregiver with the patients. In the schizophrenia group, the highest burden was felt when the caregiver is children of the patients, lowest when the caregiver is a sibling of the patient. In bipolar disorder, the highest burden was felt when a caregiver is children of the patient, the lowest when a caregiver is the parent of the patient.
| Discussion|| |
In this study, the significant burden of care was noted in both the groups. The average ZBI score (maximum score 88) was 59.11 in caregivers of the bipolar disorder group and 64.89 in caregivers of schizophrenia group. Thus, both the groups showed that they feel the burden of care of a patient with a psychiatry disorder to the level of moderate to severe This was in accordance with the previous studies,, where the results shown that the families of both group experience considerable burden with a slightly higher burden in the schizophrenia group. Findings of the current study are in contrast with Zhou et al., where the author noted that the family burden was greater in caregivers of acute bipolar disorder than among caregivers of schizophrenia. This may be due to cultural and familial differences between two geographical areas. This basic difference between the bipolar disorder and schizophrenia may be due to the chronicity and the social exclusion of the patient due to their poor social functioning. One more reason for the difference in burden between two groups can also be that schizophrenia patients also require care even during the remission period. Researchers have found that people with schizophrenia and psychosis require the same amount of social care during the remission phase that is why they feel more burden.
In this study, there is a statistically significant increase in the burden with an increase in age of patient in bipolar group, however, not in schizophrenia group. This may be because the schizophrenia patient group is younger in comparison to the bipolar group. This is in contradiction to previous studies, where no statistically significant difference between the sociodemographic variable of either group of patient or their caregivers was observed, while others found a statistically significant increase in the burden of caregivers with an increase in the age of elderly mentally ill patients,,, which makes sense since the older patients need care for their physical health too, which adds up to the demands of the patient care.
In the current study, patient sex has no significant relation to the burden of care. In Ayalew et al. and Eloia et al.,, the authors found that burden score was more in taking care of male patients than female patients. This may be because male patients are generally more demanding and because of the male dominance in society may be enjoying undue privileges.
The mean years of education were 16.10 and 13.20 years in patients with bipolar disorder and schizophrenia, respectively. No statistical significance was found between years of education of patients and caregivers' burden which is in accordance with Gupta et al. This may be justified in schizophrenia because of early-onset symptoms of patient may not be able to continue his studies further. However, in general, sense-educated patients should be easy to take care by their caregivers, so this needs further elaboration by study with large sample size.
In the current study, a statistically significant increase in burden in both the groups with an increase in the duration of illness was found, which is in accordance with previous studies.,, With longer duration of illness, there is usually exhaustion on part of the caregivers, particularly emotional and economical exhaustion plays a role because of the chronicity of these diseases. In Kuchhal et al., no significant difference was noted for the duration of illness and burden score.
In bipiolar group, there was a statistically significant increase in burden felt by caregivers with increase in caregivers' age, which was in accordance to Gupta A et al. and Prashant et al. This difference between the two groups may be because with increase in the age of the caregiver as his ability to cope up with the physical and mental stress start diminishing.
In general, female caregivers have less mean burden score compared to male caregivers, but this finding was not statistically significant. It is generally thought that female caregiver because of their natural role of caring in society should make it easy for females to take care of sick family members, but it not so found in psychiatry patients.
In this study, caregiver education was positively correlated with burden score in schizophrenia group which was statistically significant but not in bipolar group In Siddiqui and Khalid and Kuchhal et al., authors noted less educated had more burden compared with caregivers with high education. Educated caregivers are able to understand the disease better and also can add to the compliance of the patient to treatment. Educated caregivers may also be better at communicating with others regarding the perceived stress and so may feel relief in their burden.
In the current study, in schizophrenia group, the most burden was felt by children of the patient and least by siblings. In bipolar group, less burden was felt by parents of the patients. This is in contradiction with Kuchhal et al., author noted parents having more burden than a spouse. In Gupta et al. and Jungbauer and Angermeyer highest burden was felt by spouses. The structure of the family as well as their life stage as a family, for example, elderly parents caring for an adult with severe mental illness, will have its effect on the caring.
In this study, most burdens were felt by laborer and least by government employees In bipolar group, the most burden was felt by unemployed and least by government employees This is in accordance with Siddiqui and Khalid and Ayalew et al., This may be because of additional financial burden faced by laborers, unemployed that may be added to the burden as a caregiver. Low-income groups also have to take care of their daily income, which may be impacted if they have to spare time taking care of patient at home.
| Conclusion|| |
Caregivers of both bipolar group and schizophrenia group showed the considerable burden of care. Particularly, vulnerable are females, elderly, low-income groups, and longer duration of care. A psychiatrist should check burden of caregivers at regular interval and caregivers should receive parallel counseling and support for providing care to the patient so as to maintain their well-being.
Sample size was less for the present study. Sample was selected from one tertiary care hospital of Gujarat. Hence, finding of this study restricts the generalizability to the general population. Causal inference cannot always be deduced since this was a cross-sectional study. Only global interview score was considered in the present study, there is a need for a detailed analysis of all the domains of ZBI.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Böge K, Zieger A, Mungee A, Tandon A, Fuchs LM, Schomerus G, et al.
Perceived stigmatization and discrimination of people with mental illness: A survey-based study of the general population in five metropolitan cities in India. Indian J Psychiatry 2018;60:24-31.
Anderson EA, Lynch MM. A family impact analysis: The deinstitutionalization of the mentally Ill. Fam Relat 1984;33:41-6.
Ampalam P, Gunturu S, Padma V. A comparative study of caregiver burden in psychiatric illness and chronic medical illness. Indian J Psychiatry 2012;54:239-43.
] [Full text]
Krupnik Y, Pilling S, Killaspy H, Dalton J. A study of family contact with clients and staff of community mental health teams. Psychiatr Bul 2005;29:174-6.
Karlikay G, Yukse G, Varlibas F, Tireli H. Caregiver Burden in Dementia: A Study in The Turkish Population. Internet J Neurol 2005;4:12-26.
Chou KR, Chu H, Tseng CL, Lu RB. The measurement of caregiver burden. J Med Sci 2003;23:73-82.
Ganguly KK, Chadda RK, Singh TB. Caregiver burden and coping in schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2010;161:850-6.
Srivastava S. Perception of burden by caregivers of patients with schizophrenia. Indian J Psychiatry 2005;47:148-52.
] [Full text]
Vasudeva S, Sekhar CK, Rao PG. Caregivers burden of patients with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder: A sectional study. Indian J Psychol Med 2013;35:352-7.
] [Full text]
Chakrabarti S, Raj L, Kulhara P, Avasthi A, Verma SK. Comparison of the extent and pattern of family burden in affective disorders and schizophrenia. Indian J Psychiatry 1995;37:105-12.
] [Full text]
Roychaudhuri J, Mondal D, Boral A, Bhattacharya D. Family burden among long term psychiatric patients. Indian J Psychiatry 1995;37:81-5.
] [Full text]
Lin TY, Tardiff K, Donetz G, Goresky W. Ethnicity and patterns of help-seeking. Cult Med Psychiatry 1978;2:3-13.
Gonçalves-Pereira M, González-Fraile E, Santos-Zorrozúa B, Martín-Carrasco M, Fernández-Catalina P, Domínguez-Panchón AI, et al.
Assessment of the consequences of caregiving in psychosis: A psychometric comparison of the Zarit Burden Interview (ZBI) and the Involvement Evaluation Questionnaire (IEQ). Health Qual Life Outcomes 2017;15:63.
Zhou Y, Rosenheck R, Mohamed S, Ou Y, Ning Y, He H. Comparison of burden among family members of patients diagnosed with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder in a large acute psychiatric hospital in China. BMC Psychiatry 2016;16:283.
Janardhana N, Raghunandan S, Naidu DM, Saraswathi L, Seshan V. Care giving of people with severe mental illness: An Indian experience. Indian J Psychol Med 2015;37:184-94.
] [Full text]
Parija S, Yadav AK, Sreeraj VS, Patel AK, Yadav J. Burden and expressed emotion in caregivers of schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder patients: A comparative study. MAMC J Med Sci 2018;4:68-74. [Full text]
Kuchhal AK, Kuchhal A, Arya V, Pardal PK, Sharma CS, Sharma M. A study of psychological stress and burden on caregivers of schizophrenic patients. Int J Contemp Med Res 2019;6:H1-6.
Sinha V. Caregiver burden of elderly psychiatric and medically ill patients: A comparative study. J Med Sci Clin Res 2019;7:834-40.
Gupta A, Solanki RK, Koolwal GD, Gehlot S. Psychological well-being and burden in caregivers of patients with schizophrenia. Int J Med Sci Public Health 2015;4:70-6.
Eloia SC, Oliveira EN, Lopes MV, Parente JR, Eloia SM, Lima DD. Family burden among caregivers of people with mental disorders: An analysis of health services. Cien Saude Colet 2018;23:3001-11.
Ayalew M, Workicho A, Tesfaye E, Hailesilasie H, Abera M. Burden among caregivers of people with mental illness at Jimma University Medical Center, Southwest Ethiopia: A cross-sectional study. Ann Gen Psychiatry 2019;18:10.
Siddiqui S, Khalid J. Determining the caregivers' burden in caregivers of patients with mental illness. Pak J Med Sci 2019;35:1329-33.
Jungbauer J, Angermeyer MC. Living with a schizophrenic patient: A comparative study of burden as it affects parents and spouses. Psychiatry 2002;65:110-23.
Pot AM, Deeg DJ, Knipscheer CP. Institutionalization of demented elderly: The role of caregiver characteristics. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 2001;16:273-80.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6]